House Tour

This Historic Church Now Offers Endless Possibilities

This Historic Church Now Offers Endless Possibilities

This place was a church built in 1896 and has been converted into a gift shop and art studio. It’s located at 134 S Main Street in Stoddard, Wisconsin. The price was recently reduced by $10,000, bringing it to $135,000.

Specifications

  • Address: 134 S Main STREET, Stoddard, WI 54658
  • Price: $135,000
  • Sq. Ft: 2,800
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Bathrooms: 1 (with 2 half baths)
  • Year Built: 1896
  • Lot Size: 4,356 Square Feet
  • Parking/Garage: 2 car detached garage
  • Stories: Bi-Level

Old church bones with those pointed stained glass windows. Clean white looks crisp.

Old church bones with those pointed stained glass windows. Clean white looks crisp.

Inside, the diamond-pattern stained glass throws colors everywhere. Tall and narrow, very pretty.

Inside, the diamond-pattern stained glass throws colors everywhere. Tall and narrow, very pretty.

The kitchen is classic honey oak and laminate, big and functional. Feels welcoming.

The kitchen is classic honey oak and laminate, big and functional. Feels welcoming.

Gracie's Hutch exterior, white siding and pops of stained glass. Sweet little mashup.

Gracie's Hutch exterior, white siding and pops of stained glass. Sweet little mashup.

Big flex space with earthy walls and exposed beams. Casual, a little industrial.

Big flex space with earthy walls and exposed beams. Casual, a little industrial.

Different room goes softer. beige walls, plush gray carpet, easy hangout energy.

Different room goes softer. beige walls, plush gray carpet, easy hangout energy.

Utility zone is tidy. light walls, small grid window, everything where it belongs.

Utility zone is tidy. light walls, small grid window, everything where it belongs.

Another angle of the converted church. Those stained glass panels pop against the white.

Another angle of the converted church. Those stained glass panels pop against the white.

If you rustic farmhouse, this space nails the cozy palette.

If you rustic farmhouse, this space nails the cozy palette.

High ceilings, chunky beams, wood trim everywhere. Kinda nostalgic in the best way.

High ceilings, chunky beams, wood trim everywhere. Kinda nostalgic in the best way.

Details

This unique single-family residence at 134 S Main Street in Stoddard, WI, was built in 1896 and offers a blend of historic character and modern potential. The property, listed for $135,000, features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, with an additional 2 half bathrooms. The total structure area is 2,800 square feet, situated on a 4,356 square feet lot. Key features include original stained glass windows, an altar and organ alcove, and a full kitchen. The full walk-out basement with three separate exits provides significant space for various uses. Heating is provided by propane and forced air, with central air for cooling. Appliances included are a microwave, oven, range, and refrigerator. The property has high-speed internet access and a cathedral/vaulted ceiling. Parking is available in a detached 2-car garage. The lot is equipped with sidewalks, and there is an additional garden shed on the property. The property is zoned for residential use. The last price reduction was $10,000 on September 12th. The tax assessed value is $87,800, with annual taxes of $1,074. It's been on the market since June 16, 2025.

Get a new home tour in your inbox every day.